ALLcrimesfood&drugstaxestelecomcommercehealthconservationtransportationagricultureveteransbrowse all titles »
0

26 U.S.C. § 7518Tax incentives relating to merchant marine capital construction funds

submitted 40 years ago by Pub. L. 99-514 to r/title-26-INTERNAL-REVENUE-CODE · 2,891 words · no verdicts yet

in plain englishAI-generated · not legal advice

This law lets vessel owners set up tax-favored "capital construction funds" to save for new ships. Money deposited isn't taxed right away if it's later spent on qualifying vessel costs. Withdrawing it for other purposes makes that money taxable, often at the highest rate.

(a) Ceiling on deposits A vessel owner or lessee who signs an agreement under chapter 535 of title 46, United States Code, can set up a "capital construction fund" for their ships (called "agreement vessels"). Each year, the most that can be deposited into the fund is the sum of four amounts: the part of the owner's or lessee's taxable income for the year that comes from running the agreement vessels in foreign or domestic commerce, or in U.S. fisheries — figured without counting any net operating loss or net capital loss carried back, and without applying this section; the depreciation deduction allowed for the year under section 167 for the agreement vessels; if not already counted in the first amount, the net proceeds from selling an agreement vessel, or from insurance or indemnity for one; and any earnings the fund makes from investing or reinvesting its own money. If the owner leases the vessel instead of owning it, there's a limit: whatever amount the owner is required or permitted to deposit for that vessel under the depreciation-based amount above, the lessee's own deposit under that same amount gets reduced by that much. "Agreement vessel" also includes barges and containers that are part of the vessel's normal equipment and are named in the agreement. (b) Requirements as to investments Fund money must be kept in the depository named in the agreement, under trustee and fiduciary rules the Secretary sets. Normally, the fund can only be invested in interest-bearing securities the Secretary approves. With the Secretary's consent, up to 60% of the fund's assets can instead go into the stock of domestic corporations — but only stock that is fully listed and registered on a national securities exchange, and that a careful, well-informed investor seeking steady income and safety of capital would buy. If the stock in the fund ever grows to be worth more than the agreed percentage of the fund's assets, future investments and withdrawals must be managed in a way that brings the fund back toward that limit. Nonvoting preferred stock of a corporation is treated as meeting these requirements too, as long as that corporation's common stock would qualify, and the only reason the preferred stock can't be listed and registered is that it's nonvoting. (c) Nontaxability for deposits Making deposits into the fund reduces taxes in several ways: taxable income for the year goes down by whatever amount of vessel-operation income was deposited that year; gain from selling a vessel, or from insurance or indemnity proceeds, isn't counted as taxable gain if the net proceeds are deposited into the fund; earnings the fund makes from investing its money — including gains and losses — aren't counted as income while they stay in the fund; a corporation's "earnings and profits" are figured as if this section and chapter 535 of title 46 didn't exist; and when figuring the accumulated earnings tax under section 531, money sitting in the fund doesn't count. These tax breaks apply only to amounts deposited on time, under the agreement and the joint regulations. (d) Establishment of accounts The fund must be split into three accounts: the capital account, the capital gain account, and the ordinary income account. The capital account holds: depreciation-based deposits; sale, insurance, or indemnity proceeds, except the part that was taxable gain; the deductible share of any dividend the fund receives; and tax-exempt interest under section 103. The capital gain account holds gains on fund assets held more than 6 months, minus losses on assets held more than 6 months. The ordinary income account holds: vessel-operation income; gains on assets held 6 months or less, minus losses on assets held 6 months or less; taxable interest and other ordinary income the fund earns (not counting the tax-exempt interest or deductible dividend share already placed in the capital account); ordinary income from selling a vessel or from insurance or indemnity proceeds; and the taxable part of any dividend the fund receives. Capital losses can only offset gains of the same kind — long-held losses offset long-held gains, short-held losses offset short-held gains — except when the fund is finally closed out. (e) Purposes of qualified withdrawals A withdrawal is "qualified" only if it follows the agreement's terms and pays for: buying, building, or rebuilding a qualified vessel; buying, building, or rebuilding barges or containers that are part of a qualified vessel's equipment; or paying down debt used to buy, build, or rebuild a qualified vessel, barge, or container. Except as regulations allow, barges and containers under the second purpose — and the barge or container part of the third — must have been built in the United States. If the Secretary decides someone isn't meeting a major obligation under their agreement, the Secretary can, after notice and a chance for a hearing, treat all or part of the fund as if it had been withdrawn improperly — a "nonqualified withdrawal." (f) Tax treatment of qualified withdrawals Qualified withdrawals come out of the accounts in this order: first the capital account, second the capital gain account, third the ordinary income account. If part of a qualified withdrawal for a vessel, barge, or container comes from the ordinary income account, that vessel's, barge's, or container's basis (the value used to figure future gain or loss) is reduced by that amount. The same rule applies to amounts coming from the capital gain account. If part of a qualified withdrawal used to pay down debt comes from the ordinary income or capital gain account, that same kind of basis reduction is applied — in the order joint regulations set — across the vessels, barges, and containers the person owns. Any part of the withdrawal left over after that is instead treated as a nonqualified withdrawal. If property whose basis was reduced this way is later disposed of, any gain from that disposal — up to the total amount the basis was reduced — is treated as if it were an amount withdrawn from the ordinary income account on the date of the disposal. This doesn't apply if the person redeposits an amount, set under joint regulations, that restores the fund to roughly where it was before the withdrawal. (g) Tax treatment of nonqualified withdrawals Except as covered in subsection (h), any withdrawal that isn't a qualified withdrawal is a nonqualified withdrawal. Nonqualified withdrawals come out of the accounts in the opposite order: first the ordinary income account, second the capital gain account, third the capital account. Within each account, amounts are normally treated as withdrawn oldest-first — except two kinds, which are treated as withdrawn newest-first: withdrawals for research, development, and design costs for new and advanced ship design, machinery, and equipment; and amounts treated as nonqualified under the basis-reduction rule described above. Tax treatment: an amount from the ordinary income account is included in gross income as ordinary income for the year of the withdrawal. An amount from the capital gain account is included in income for that year as a gain from an asset held more than 6 months. For the period up to the tax due date for the year of the withdrawal: no interest under section 6601 and no addition to tax under section 6651 applies; instead, interest at a special "applicable rate" applies to the extra tax on these amounts, running from the tax due date for the year the money was originally deposited in the fund; and no interest applies to the 25-year-rule amounts described below, or to a nonqualified withdrawal arising from the recapture rule in section 606(5) of the Merchant Marine Act, 1936, as in effect on December 31, 1969. The "applicable rate" of interest for a nonqualified withdrawal is set jointly, for each year, by the Secretary of the Treasury and the applicable Secretary. It's pegged to 8%, adjusted to reflect how the prior year's money rates and investment returns compare to those for calendar year 1970. 25-year rule: an increasing share of any amount left in the fund a long time after it was deposited is automatically treated as a nonqualified withdrawal — 20% at the close of the 26th taxable year after the deposit year, 40% at the close of the 27th, 60% at the close of the 28th, 80% at the close of the 29th, and 100% at the close of the 30th. A fund's earnings for a year (other than net gains) are treated as deposited that year for this rule. An amount is not treated as "remaining" in the fund, though, if there is already a binding contract, by the close of that year, for a qualified withdrawal of that amount for a specific identified item. If the Secretary decides a fund's balance is more than is appropriate for that person's vessel construction plans, the excess is treated as a nonqualified withdrawal — unless the person develops real program objectives within 3 years to use up that excess. Amounts already in a fund on January 1, 1987, are treated as deposited on that date. Tax rate: for the year of a nonqualified withdrawal (including a 25-year-rule amount), the withdrawal is excluded from gross income, but the regular tax for that year is increased by the withdrawal amount multiplied by the highest tax rate under section 1 (section 11 for a corporation). For a taxpayer other than a corporation, the part of a nonqualified withdrawal from the capital gain account is taxed at no more than 20% where section 1(h) applies. If part of a nonqualified withdrawal is properly traced to deposits — not deposit earnings — that did not reduce the taxpayer's tax liability in an earlier year, that part is treated differently: it isn't taxed under the rule just described, and instead an equal amount is treated as if it were allowed as a deduction under section 172 for the year of the withdrawal. Any amount excluded from gross income this way is also excluded when figuring taxable income under section 172(b)(2). (h) Certain corporate reorganizations and changes in partnerships Under joint regulations, a transfer of a fund from one person to another, as part of a transaction to which section 381 applies, may be treated as if it were not a nonqualified withdrawal. A similar rule applies to a continuation of a partnership. (i) Definitions Any term this section uses that is also defined in chapter 535 of title 46, United States Code — including the term "Secretary" — has the meaning that chapter gave it as of the date this section became law.
the actual law source: uscode.house.gov ↗public domain
(a) Ceiling on deposits
(1) In general

The amount deposited in a fund established under chapter 535 of title 46 of the United States Code (hereinafter in this section referred to as a “capital construction fund”) shall not exceed for any taxable year the sum of:

(A)

that portion of the taxable income of the owner or lessee for such year (computed as provided in chapter 1 but without regard to the carryback of any net operating loss or net capital loss and without regard to this section) which is attributable to the operation of the agreement vessels in the foreign or domestic commerce of the United States or in the fisheries of the United States,

(B)

the amount allowable as a deduction under section 167 for such year with respect to the agreement vessels,

(C)

if the transaction is not taken into account for purposes of subparagraph (A), the net proceeds (as defined in joint regulations) from—

(i)

the sale or other disposition of any agreement vessel, or

(ii)

insurance or indemnity attributable to any agreement vessel, and

(D)

the receipts from the investment or reinvestment of amounts held in such fund.

(2) Limitations on deposits by lessees

In the case of a lessee, the maximum amount which may be deposited with respect to an agreement vessel by reason of paragraph (1)(B) for any period shall be reduced by any amount which, under an agreement entered into under chapter 535 of title 46, United States Code, the owner is required or permitted to deposit for such period with respect to such vessel by reason of paragraph (1)(B).

(3) Certain barges and containers included

For purposes of paragraph (1), the term “agreement vessel” includes barges and containers which are part of the complement of such vessel and which are provided for in the agreement.

(b) Requirements as to investments
(1) In general

Amounts in any capital construction fund shall be kept in the depository or depositories specified in the agreement and shall be subject to such trustee and other fiduciary requirements as may be specified by the Secretary.

(2) Limitation on fund investments

Amounts in any capital construction fund may be invested only in interest-bearing securities approved by the Secretary; except that, if such Secretary consents thereto, an agreed percentage (not in excess of 60 percent) of the assets of the fund may be invested in the stock of domestic corporations. Such stock must be currently fully listed and registered on an exchange registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission as a national securities exchange, and must be stock which would be acquired by prudent men of discretion and intelligence in such matters who are seeking a reasonable income and the preservation of their capital. If at any time the fair market value of the stock in the fund is more than the agreed percentage of the assets in the fund, any subsequent investment of amounts deposited in the fund, and any subsequent withdrawal from the fund, shall be made in such a way as to tend to restore the fund to a situation in which the fair market value of the stock does not exceed such agreed percentage.

(3) Investment in certain preferred stock permitted

For purposes of this subsection, if the common stock of a corporation meets the requirements of this subsection and if the preferred stock of such corporation would meet such requirements but for the fact that it cannot be listed and registered as required because it is nonvoting stock, such preferred stock shall be treated as meeting the requirements of this subsection.

(c) Nontaxability for deposits
(1) In general

For purposes of this title—

(A)

taxable income (determined without regard to this section and chapter 535 of title 46, United States Code) for the taxable year shall be reduced by an amount equal to the amount deposited for the taxable year out of amounts referred to in subsection (a)(1)(A),

(B)

gain from a transaction referred to in subsection (a)(1)(C) shall not be taken into account if an amount equal to the net proceeds (as defined in joint regulations) from such transaction is deposited in the fund,

(C)

the earnings (including gains and losses) from the investment and reinvestment of amounts held in the fund shall not be taken into account,

(D)

the earnings and profits (within the meaning of section 316) of any corporation shall be determined without regard to this section and chapter 535 of title 46, United States Code, and

(E)

in applying the tax imposed by section 531 (relating to the accumulated earnings tax), amounts while held in the fund shall not be taken into account.

(2) Only qualified deposits eligible for treatment

Paragraph (1) shall apply with respect to any amount only if such amount is deposited in the fund pursuant to the agreement and not later than the time provided in joint regulations.

(d) Establishment of accounts

For purposes of this section—

(1) In general

Within a capital construction fund 3 accounts shall be maintained:

(A)

the capital account,

(B)

the capital gain account, and

(C)

the ordinary income account.

(2) Capital account

The capital account shall consist of—

(A)

amounts referred to in subsection (a)(1)(B),

(B)

amounts referred to in subsection (a)(1)(C) other than that portion thereof which represents gain not taken into account by reason of subsection (c)(1)(B),

(C)

the percentage applicable under section 243(a)(1) of any dividend received by the fund with respect to which the person maintaining the fund would (but for subsection (c)(1)(C)) be allowed a deduction under section 243, and

(D)

interest income exempt from taxation under section 103.

(3) Capital gain account

The capital gain account shall consist of—

(A)

amounts representing capital gains on assets held for more than 6 months and referred to in subsection (a)(1)(C) or (a)(1)(D), reduced by

(B)

amounts representing capital losses on assets held in the fund for more than 6 months.

(4) Ordinary income account

The ordinary income account shall consist of—

(A)

amounts referred to in subsection (a)(1)(A),

(B)
(i)

amounts representing capital gains on assets held for 6 months or less and referred to in subsection (a)(1)(C) or (a)(1)(D), reduced by

(ii)

amounts representing capital losses on assets held in the fund for 6 months or less,

(C)

interest (not including any tax-exempt interest referred to in paragraph (2)(D)) and other ordinary income (not including any dividend referred to in subparagraph (E)) received on assets held in the fund,

(D)

ordinary income from a transaction described in subsection (a)(1)(C), and

(E)

the portion of any dividend referred to in paragraph (2)(C) not taken into account under such paragraph.

(5) Capital losses only allowed to offset certain gains

Except on termination of a capital construction fund, capital losses referred to in paragraph (3)(B) or in paragraph (4)(B)(ii) shall be allowed only as an offset to gains referred to in paragraph (3)(A) or (4)(B)(i), respectively.

(e) Purposes of qualified withdrawals
(1) In general

A qualified withdrawal from the fund is one made in accordance with the terms of the agreement but only if it is for:

(A)

the acquisition, construction, or reconstruction of a qualified vessel,

(B)

the acquisition, construction, or reconstruction of barges and containers which are part of the complement of a qualified vessel, or

(C)

the payment of the principal on indebtedness incurred in connection with the acquisition, construction, or reconstruction of a qualified vessel or a barge or container which is part of the complement of a qualified vessel.

Except to the extent provided in regulations prescribed by the Secretary, subparagraph (B), and so much of subparagraph (C) as relates only to barges and containers, shall apply only with respect to barges and containers constructed in the United States.

(2) Penalty for failing to fulfill any substantial obligation

Under joint regulations, if the Secretary determines that any substantial obligation under any agreement is not being fulfilled, he may, after notice and opportunity for hearing to the person maintaining the fund, treat the entire fund or any portion thereof as an amount withdrawn from the fund in a nonqualified withdrawal.

(f) Tax treatment of qualified withdrawals
(1) Ordering rule

Any qualified withdrawal from a fund shall be treated—

(A)

first as made out of the capital account,

(B)

second as made out of the capital gain account, and

(C)

third as made out of the ordinary income account.

(2) Adjustment to basis of vessel, etc., where withdrawal from ordinary income account

If any portion of a qualified withdrawal for a vessel, barge, or container is made out of the ordinary income account, the basis of such vessel, barge, or container shall be reduced by an amount equal to such portion.

(3) Adjustment to basis of vessel, etc., where withdrawal from capital gain account

If any portion of a qualified withdrawal for a vessel, barge, or container is made out of the capital gain account, the basis of such vessel, barge, or container shall be reduced by an amount equal to such portion.

(4) Adjustment to basis of vessels, etc., where withdrawals pay principal on debt

If any portion of a qualified withdrawal to pay the principal on any indebtedness is made out of the ordinary income account or the capital gain account, then an amount equal to the aggregate reduction which would be required by paragraphs (2) and (3) if this were a qualified withdrawal for a purpose described in such paragraphs shall be applied, in the order provided in joint regulations, to reduce the basis of vessels, barges, and containers owned by the person maintaining the fund. Any amount of a withdrawal remaining after the application of the preceding sentence shall be treated as a nonqualified withdrawal.

(5) Ordinary income recapture of basis reduction

If any property the basis of which was reduced under paragraph (2), (3), or (4) is disposed of, any gain realized on such disposition, to the extent it does not exceed the aggregate reduction in the basis of such property under such paragraphs, shall be treated as an amount referred to in subsection (g)(3)(A) which was withdrawn on the date of such disposition. Subject to such conditions and requirements as may be provided in joint regulations, the preceding sentence shall not apply to a disposition where there is a redeposit in an amount determined under joint regulations which will, insofar as practicable, restore the fund to the position it was in before the withdrawal.

(g) Tax treatment of nonqualified withdrawals
(1) In general

Except as provided in subsection (h), any withdrawal from a capital construction fund which is not a qualified withdrawal shall be treated as a nonqualified withdrawal.

(2) Ordering rule

Any nonqualified withdrawal from a fund shall be treated—

(A)

first as made out of the ordinary income account,

(B)

second as made out of the capital gain account, and

(C)

third as made out of the capital account.

For purposes of this section, items withdrawn from any account shall be treated as withdrawn on a first-in-first-out basis; except that (i) any nonqualified withdrawal for research, development, and design expenses incident to new and advanced ship design, machinery and equipment, and (ii) any amount treated as a nonqualified withdrawal under the second sentence of subsection (f)(4), shall be treated as withdrawn on a last-in-first-out basis.

(3) Operating rules

For purposes of this title—

(A)

any amount referred to in paragraph (2)(A) shall be included in income as an item of ordinary income for the taxable year in which the withdrawal is made,

(B)

any amount referred to in paragraph (2)(B) shall be included in income for the taxable year in which the withdrawal is made as an item of gain realized during such year from the disposition of an asset held for more than 6 months, and

(C)

for the period on or before the last date prescribed for payment of tax for the taxable year in which this withdrawal is made—

(i)

no interest shall be payable under section 6601 and no addition to the tax shall be payable under section 6651,

(ii)

interest on the amount of the additional tax attributable to any item referred to in subparagraph (A) or (B) shall be paid at the applicable rate (as defined in paragraph (4)) from the last date prescribed for payment of the tax for the taxable year for which such item was deposited in the fund, and

(iii)

no interest shall be payable on amounts referred to in clauses (i) and (ii) of paragraph (2) or in the case of any nonqualified withdrawal arising from the application of the recapture provision of section 606(5) of the Merchant Marine Act, 1936, as in effect on December 31, 1969.

(4) Interest rate

For purposes of paragraph (3)(C)(ii), the applicable rate of interest for any nonqualified withdrawal shall be determined and published jointly by the Secretary of the Treasury or his delegate and the applicable Secretary and shall bear a relationship to 8 percent which the Secretaries determine under joint regulations to be comparable to the relationship which the money rates and investment yields for the calendar year immediately preceding the beginning of the taxable year bear to the money rates and investment yields for the calendar year 1970.

(5) Amount not withdrawn from fund after 25 years from deposit taxed as nonqualified withdrawal
(A) In general

The applicable percentage of any amount which remains in a capital construction fund at the close of the 26th, 27th, 28th, 29th, or 30th taxable year following the taxable year for which such amount was deposited shall be treated as a nonqualified withdrawal in accordance with the following table:

 If the amount remains in the fund

  at the close of the—

The applicable percentage is—

26th taxable year

20 percent  

27th taxable year

40 percent  

28th taxable year

60 percent  

29th taxable year

80 percent  

30th taxable year

100 percent.

(B) Earnings treated as deposits

The earnings of any capital construction fund for any taxable year (other than net gains) shall be treated for purposes of this paragraph as an amount deposited for such taxable year.

(C) Amounts committed treated as withdrawn

For purposes of subparagraph (A), an amount shall not be treated as remaining in a capital construction fund at the close of any taxable year to the extent there is a binding contract at the close of such year for a qualified withdrawal of such amount with respect to an identified item for which such withdrawal may be made.

(D) Authority to treat excess funds as withdrawn

If the Secretary determines that the balance in any capital construction fund exceeds the amount which is appropriate to meet the vessel construction program objectives of the person who established such fund, the amount of such excess shall be treated as a nonqualified withdrawal under subparagraph (A) unless such person develops appropriate program objectives within 3 years to dissipate such excess.

(E) Amounts in fund on January 1, 1987

For purposes of this paragraph, all amounts in a capital construction fund on January 1, 1987, shall be treated as deposited in such fund on such date.

(6) Nonqualified withdrawals taxed at highest marginal rate
(A) In general

In the case of any taxable year for which there is a nonqualified withdrawal (including any amount so treated under paragraph (5)), the tax imposed by chapter 1 shall be determined—

(i)

by excluding such withdrawal from gross income, and

(ii)

by increasing the tax imposed by chapter 1 by the product of the amount of such withdrawal and the highest rate of tax specified in section 1 (section 11 in the case of a corporation).

In the case of a taxpayer other than a corporation, with respect to the portion of any nonqualified withdrawal made out of the capital gain account during a taxable year to which section 1(h) applies, the rate of tax taken into account under the preceding sentence shall not exceed 20 percent.

(B) Tax benefit rule

If any portion of a nonqualified withdrawal is properly attributable to deposits (other than earnings on deposits) made by the taxpayer in any taxable year which did not reduce the taxpayer’s liability for tax under chapter 1 for any taxable year preceding the taxable year in which such withdrawal occurs—

(i)

such portion shall not be taken into account under subparagraph (A), and

(ii)

an amount equal to such portion shall be treated as allowed as a deduction under section 172 for the taxable year in which such withdrawal occurs.

(C) Coordination with deduction for net operating losses

Any nonqualified withdrawal excluded from gross income under subparagraph (A) shall be excluded in determining taxable income under section 172(b)(2).

(h) Certain corporate reorganizations and changes in partnerships

Under joint regulations—

(1)

a transfer of a fund from one person to another person in a transaction to which section 381 applies may be treated as if such transaction did not constitute a nonqualified withdrawal, and

(2)

a similar rule shall be applied in the case of a continuation of a partnership.

(i) Definitions

For purposes of this section, any term defined in chapter 535 of title 46, United States Code, which is also used in this section (including the definition of “Secretary”) shall have the meaning given such term by such chapter as in effect on the date of the enactment of this section.

Source credit: (Added Pub. L. 99–514, title II, § 261(b), Oct. 22, 1986, 100 Stat. 2208; amended Pub. L. 100–647, title I, §§ 1002(m)(1), 1018(u)(23), Nov. 10, 1988, 102 Stat. 3382, 3591; Pub. L. 101–508, title XI, § 11101(d)(7)(A), Nov. 5, 1990, 104 Stat. 1388–405; Pub. L. 105–34, title III, § 311(c)(2), Aug. 5, 1997, 111 Stat. 835; Pub. L. 108–27, title III, § 301(a)(2)(D), May 28, 2003, 117 Stat. 758; Pub. L. 109–304, § 17(e)(6), Oct. 6, 2006, 120 Stat. 1708; Pub. L. 112–240, title I, § 102(c)(1)(D), Jan. 2, 2013, 126 Stat. 2319; Pub. L. 113–295, div. A, title II, § 221(a)(117), Dec. 19, 2014, 128 Stat. 4054; Pub. L. 115–97, title I, § 13001(b)(2)(Q), (7), Dec. 22, 2017, 131 Stat. 2097, 2098; Pub. L. 115–141, div. U, title IV, § 401(a)(352), Mar. 23, 2018, 132 Stat. 1201.)

history & why it existsrecord from the source credit
  • 1986Enacted · Pub. L. 99-514 · 100 Stat. 2208
  • 1988Amended · Pub. L. 100-647 · 102 Stat. 3382, 3591
  • 1990Amended · Pub. L. 101-508 · 104 Stat. 1388
  • 1997Amended · Pub. L. 105-34 · 111 Stat. 835
  • 2003Amended · Pub. L. 108-27 · 117 Stat. 758
  • 2006Amended · Pub. L. 109-304 · 120 Stat. 1708
  • 2013Amended · Pub. L. 112-240 · 126 Stat. 2319
  • 2014Amended · Pub. L. 113-295 · 128 Stat. 4054
  • 2017Amended · Pub. L. 115-97 · 131 Stat. 2097, 2098
  • 2018Amended · Pub. L. 115-141 · 132 Stat. 1201

A history note hasn’t been published yet. The record shows enactment by Pub. L. 99-514 on 1986-10-22.

all 0 arguments · sorted by: best

0/280

no arguments yet — make the first case