42 U.S.C. § 6344 — Additional incentives for recovery, use, and prevention of industrial waste energy
submitted 19 years ago by Pub. L. 94-163 to r/title-42-THE-PUBLIC-HEALTH-AND-WELFARE · 1,693 words · no verdicts yet
This section requires a State utility regulator or a nonregulated electric utility to consider, after a project sponsor asks, whether to adopt a standard helping listed waste-energy recovery projects dispose of excess power. It describes four options, the rates and limits for two of them, hearing and reporting rules, and what happens if the standard is not adopted.
(a) Consideration of the standard. (1) Within 180 days after receiving a request from a project* sponsor, owner*, or operator, the State* regulatory authority for each electric utility over which it has rate-setting authority, or a nonregulated electric utility, must give public notice and hold a hearing about the standard in subsection (b). After the hearing, it must decide whether adopting the standard is appropriate to carry out this part. (2) For that decision and any court review, this section adds to the otherwise applicable State law. (3) This part does not prevent the authority or utility from deciding under otherwise applicable State law that adopting the standard is not appropriate. (b) Standard for selling excess power. The standard must make an owner or operator of a waste-energy recovery project listed on the Registry* and producing net excess power* eligible for at least one option in subsection (c), subject to subsection (d)'s rates and limits. (c) Options. (1) The utility must buy the project's net excess power while the project operates, under a contract for that purchase. (2) The utility must transmit the power for the owner or operator to as many as three separate places on its system, where the owner or operator may sell directly to third parties. (3) The State and utility must allow the project owner or operator to build and operate private electric wires to as many as three purchasers within three miles of the project. They must waive or change laws that would otherwise prohibit the wires, allow the wires to use or cross public rights-of-way, and give them the same safety, zoning, land-use, and other legal treatment* as the utility's wires, without regulating the project as a public utility. (A) The State may not give anyone eminent-domain power to take or cross private property for the wires. (B) The wires must be physically separate from and not connected to the utility system, except on the customer side of the utility's revenue meter and only in a way that prevents electricity from entering the utility system or disrupting it. (4) The utility and project owner or operator may agree on another arrangement and related payments or rates if it is mutually satisfactory and follows State law. (d) Rate conditions and criteria. (1) Definitions. (A) “Per unit distribution costs” means, in kilowatt-hours, the utility's depreciated book-value distribution-system costs divided by the amount of utility electricity sold or transmitted at the distribution level during the previous year. (B) “Per unit distribution margin” means the following. For a State-regulated utility, it is the per-unit gross pretax profit obtained by multiplying the State-approved rate of return for the utility's distribution-system assets by the per-unit distribution costs. For a nonregulated utility, it is a per-unit contribution to net revenues obtained by multiplying the per-unit distribution costs by a percentage that is the greater of the percentage calculated by dividing the prior year's net-revenue payments or contributions to owners or subscribers by the utility's prior-year gross revenues, or 10 percent. (C) “Per unit transmission costs” means the total cost of transmission services the utility buys or provides, calculated per kilowatt-hour as included in the utility's retail rate. (2) The purchase and transport options in subsection (c)(1) and (2) must use rates reflecting these components when paragraph (3) applies. (3) Applicable rates. (A) For a sale under subsection (c)(1), the utility must pay per kilowatt-hour the full, undiscounted retail rate the facility pays the utility for power, minus per-unit distribution costs applicable to the type of purchasing utility. If the power is available at a voltage that must be transformed to or from a voltage above 25 kilovolts before the utility can resell it, subtract per-unit transmission costs too. (B) For utility transport under subsection (c)(2), the owner or operator must pay a transport rate equal to the applicable per-unit distribution costs plus per-unit distribution margin. If transformation to or from a voltage above 25 kilovolts is needed to transport the power to the named third-party purchasers, add per-unit transmission costs. In a State with a competitive retail electricity market, use the applicable rate for similar transportation instead of a rate calculated under this paragraph. (4) Limitations. (A) A sale or transport rate must change over time as the utility's underlying costs or rates change, and must use the same time-sensitive features and billing periods as the utility's retail sale or transport rates. (B) A utility need not buy or transport more power than the capacity of its wires, meter, or other equipment serving the site, unless the project owner or operator agrees to pay necessary and reasonable upgrade costs. (e) Procedures. (1) The consideration must follow public notice and a hearing. The decision must be written, include findings, rely on the hearing evidence, and be public. (2) The Administrator* may intervene as a matter of right to calculate likely energy and emissions savings from choosing one or more options, calculate costs and benefits for ratepayers and the utility, and advocate for the waste-energy recovery opportunity. (3) Except for paragraphs (1) and (2), the regulator or nonregulated utility sets the procedures. If several projects seek consideration at the same time from the same utility, one proceeding may cover them all only if each project's circumstances and merits receive full attention and a separate judgment is made for each. (f) Implementation. (1) Consistent with otherwise applicable State law, the regulator or nonregulated utility may implement the standard or decline to implement it. (2) If it declines, it must give its reasons in writing, and the reasons must be public. The Administrator must include in an annual report to Congress the lost waste-heat-recovery opportunities for the project, identify the utility, and state the calculated lost energy and emissions savings. The project sponsor may file a new petition about the project after two years have passed since the decision not to implement the standard.
Not later than 180 days after the receipt by a State* regulatory authority (with respect to each electric utility for which the authority has ratemaking authority), or nonregulated electric utility, of a request from a project* sponsor or owner* or operator, the State regulatory authority or nonregulated electric utility shall—
provide public notice and conduct a hearing respecting the standard established by subsection (b); and
on the basis of the hearing, consider and make a determination whether or not it is appropriate to implement the standard to carry out the purposes of this part.
For purposes of any determination under paragraph (1) and any review of the determination in any court, the purposes of this section supplement otherwise applicable State law.
Nothing in this part prohibits any State regulatory authority or nonregulated electric utility from making any determination that it is not appropriate to adopt any standard described in paragraph (1), pursuant to authority under otherwise applicable State law.
For purposes of this section, the standard referred to in subsection (a) shall provide that an owner or operator of a waste energy* recovery project identified on the Registry* that generates net excess power* shall be eligible to benefit from at least 1 of the options described in subsection (c) for disposal of the net excess power in accordance with the rate conditions and limitations described in subsection (d).
The options referred to in subsection (b) are as follows:
The electric utility shall purchase the net excess power from the owner or operator of the eligible waste energy recovery project during the operation of the project under a contract entered into for that purpose.
The electric utility shall transmit the net excess power on behalf of the project owner or operator to up to 3 separate locations on the system of the utility for direct sale by the owner or operator to third parties at those locations.
The State and the electric utility shall permit, and shall waive or modify such laws as would otherwise prohibit, the construction and operation of private electric wires constructed, owned, and operated by the project owner or operator, to transport the power to up to 3 purchasers within a 3-mile radius of the project, allowing the wires to use or cross public rights-of-way, without subjecting the project to regulation as a public utility, and according the wires the same treatment* for safety, zoning, land use, and other legal privileges as apply or would apply to the wires of the utility, except that—
there shall be no grant of any power of eminent domain to take or cross private property for the wires; and
the wires shall be physically segregated and not interconnected with any portion of the system of the utility, except on the customer side of the revenue meter of the utility and in a manner that precludes any possible export of the electricity onto the utility system, or disruption of the system.
The utility and the owner or operator of the project may reach agreement on any alternate arrangement and payments or rates associated with the arrangement that is mutually satisfactory and in accord with State law.
In this subsection:
The term “per unit distribution costs” means (in kilowatt hours) the quotient obtained by dividing—
the depreciated book-value distribution system costs of a utility; by
the volume of utility electricity sales or transmission during the previous year at the distribution level.
The term “per unit distribution margin” means—
in the case of a State-regulated electric utility, a per-unit gross pretax profit equal to the product obtained by multiplying—
the State-approved percentage rate of return for the utility for distribution system assets; by
the per unit distribution costs; and
in the case of a nonregulated utility, a per unit contribution to net revenues determined multiplying—
the percentage (but not less than 10 percent) obtained by dividing—
the amount of any net revenue payment or contribution to the owners or subscribers of the nonregulated utility during the prior year; by
the gross revenues of the utility during the prior year to obtain a percentage; by
the per unit distribution costs.
The term “per unit transmission costs” means the total cost of those transmission services purchased or provided by a utility on a per-kilowatt-hour basis as included in the retail rate of the utility.
The options described in paragraphs (1) and (2) in subsection (c) shall be offered under purchase and transport rate conditions that reflect the rate components defined under paragraph (1) as applicable under the circumstances described in paragraph (3).
Sales made by a project owner or operator of a facility under the option described in subsection (c)(1) shall be paid for on a per kilowatt hour basis that shall equal the full undiscounted retail rate paid to the utility for power purchased by the facility minus per unit distribution costs, that applies to the type of utility purchasing the power.
If the net excess power is made available for purchase at voltages that must be transformed to or from voltages exceeding 25 kilovolts to be available for resale by the utility, the purchase price shall further be reduced by per unit transmission costs.
Transportation by utilities of power on behalf of the owner or operator of a project under the option described in subsection (c)(2) shall incur a transportation rate that shall equal the per unit distribution costs and per unit distribution margin, that applies to the type of utility transporting the power.
If the net excess power is made available for transportation at voltages that must be transformed to or from voltages exceeding 25 kilovolts to be transported to the designated third-party purchasers, the transport rate shall further be increased by per unit transmission costs.
In a State with a competitive retail market for electricity, the applicable transportation rate for similar transportation shall be applied in lieu of any rate calculated under this paragraph.
Any rate established for sale or transportation under this section shall—
be modified over time with changes in the underlying costs or rates of the electric utility; and
reflect the same time-sensitivity and billing periods as are established in the retail sales or transportation rates offered by the utility.
No utility shall be required to purchase or transport a quantity of net excess power under this section that exceeds the available capacity of the wires, meter, or other equipment of the electric utility serving the site unless the owner or operator of the project agrees to pay necessary and reasonable upgrade costs.
The consideration referred to in subsection (a) shall be made after public notice and hearing.
The determination referred to in subsection (a) shall be—
in writing;
based on findings included in the determination and on the evidence presented at the hearing; and
available to the public.
The Administrator may intervene as a matter of right in a proceeding conducted under this section—
to calculate—
the energy and emissions likely to be saved by electing to adopt 1 or more of the options; and
the costs and benefits to ratepayers and the utility; and
to advocate for the waste-energy recovery opportunity.
Except as otherwise provided in paragraphs (1) and (2), the procedures for the consideration and determination referred to in subsection (a) shall be the procedures established by the State regulatory authority or the nonregulated electric utility.
If there is more than 1 project seeking consideration simultaneously in connection with the same utility, the proceeding may encompass all such projects, if full attention is paid to individual circumstances and merits and an individual judgment is reached with respect to each project.
The State regulatory authority (with respect to each electric utility for which the authority has ratemaking authority) or nonregulated electric utility may, to the extent consistent with otherwise applicable State law—
implement the standard determined under this section; or
decline to implement any such standard.
If a State regulatory authority (with respect to each electric utility for which the authority has ratemaking authority) or nonregulated electric utility declines to implement any standard established by this section, the authority or nonregulated electric utility shall state in writing the reasons for declining to implement the standard.
The statement of reasons shall be available to the public.
The Administrator shall include in an annual report submitted to Congress a description of the lost opportunities for waste-heat recovery from the project described in subparagraph (A), specifically identifying the utility and stating the quantity of lost energy and emissions savings calculated.
If a State regulatory authority (with respect to each electric utility for which the authority has ratemaking authority) or nonregulated electric utility declines to implement the standard established by this section, the project sponsor may submit a new petition under this section with respect to the project at any time after the date that is 2 years after the date on which the State regulatory authority or nonregulated utility declined to implement the standard.
Source credit: (Pub. L. 94–163, title III, § 374, as added Pub. L. 110–140, title IV, § 451(a), Dec. 19, 2007, 121 Stat. 1628.)
- 2007Enacted · Pub. L. 94-163 · 121 Stat. 1628
A history note hasn’t been published yet. The record shows enactment by Pub. L. 94-163 on 2007-12-19.
all 0 arguments · sorted by: best
no arguments yet — make the first case